Politics & ElectionsUS News

Democrats’ Midterm Trifectas Put National Popular Vote Compact Within Reach of 270 Electoral Votes

Eighteen states and D.C. already hold 222 votes under the compact; Democratic gains in Arizona, Michigan, Nevada, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin could push the total past the threshold needed to make the national popular vote decisive.

Tommy FlynnTommy Flynn
Vote Here sign
Vote Here sign -- Lorie Shaull

Democratic control of five additional state governments following the November midterms has moved the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact within striking distance of the 270 electoral votes required for it to take effect, according to reporting by Just the News and the compact’s own status page.

The compact, first proposed in 2006, commits member states to award their electors to the winner of the national popular vote rather than the winner of their own statewide vote. It becomes operative only when states controlling at least 270 electoral votes have enacted it. As of this week, 18 states and the District of Columbia have passed the measure into law, accounting for 222 votes.

Just the News reported that Democrats secured trifectas—control of both legislative chambers and the governorship—in Arizona, Michigan, Nevada, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin. Those five states hold a combined 61 electoral votes. If all five enact the compact, the total would reach 283. Even without Arizona, the remaining four would put the compact over 270.

Attorney General Todd Blanche, appearing on “Life, Liberty, and Levin,” said the arrangement “shouldn’t get past the district court” and that he is “optimistic that the Supreme Court will never even have to deal with this.” He added that the Justice Department would take the matter to the high court if necessary.

Constitutional questions center on two provisions. Article II, Section 1 gives each state’s legislature authority over the manner of appointing electors. Article I, Section 10 requires congressional consent for interstate compacts. Courts have sometimes read the Compact Clause more narrowly, requiring consent only when a compact enlarges state power at the expense of the federal government or other states. The Supreme Court in Chiafalo v. Washington (2020) upheld state laws binding electors to the statewide winner, but has not ruled on coordinated interstate agreements that ignore statewide results.

The compact is not yet in force and would not have altered the 2024 outcome, in which President Trump won both the popular vote and the Electoral College. Supporters, including some newly elected Democratic governors, have framed it as a democracy measure. Wisconsin’s incoming Gov. David Crowley and Pennsylvania’s Gov. Josh Shapiro have expressed interest in popular-vote reforms, according to SpotlightPA. New Jersey Gov. Mikie Sherrill, whose state has already joined, told MSNOW that “our votes in New Jersey are worth about one fifth of what a vote in Wyoming is.”

Critics note that the arrangement would force states to award electors to a candidate their own voters rejected and that it concentrates the effect of any fraud or irregularities in large-population states across the entire national tally. Heritage Foundation analyses have long argued that the Electoral College encourages candidates to build geographically broad coalitions and isolates the impact of fraud to individual states.

No state has yet introduced legislation in the new sessions. Legal challenges are expected once the compact approaches or crosses the 270-vote mark. Standing and ripeness issues previously led courts to dismiss early suits without reaching the merits.

Support Independent Conservative News

RWTNews is independent conservative news — no corporate backing, no agenda driven by advertisers. We rely entirely on readers like you to keep the lights on and the truth coming. If you've found value in what you read here, consider supporting us with a one-time or monthly contribution. Every dollar goes directly toward keeping this site running and growing.

$

Secured by Stripe. Your payment info is never stored on our servers.

You May Also Like