Appeals Court Declines to Rehear McIver Case; ICE Confrontation Charges Against Congresswoman Proceed
The Third Circuit on Thursday refused to reconsider its earlier ruling that legislative immunity does not bar at least two charges against Rep. LaMonica McIver.

The full U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit on Thursday denied Rep. LaMonica McIver’s petition for rehearing, leaving in place an August panel decision that two of three federal charges against the New Jersey Democrat may proceed.
The charges arise from a May 2025 confrontation outside the Delaney Hall Immigration and Customs Enforcement facility in Newark during an unannounced oversight visit that also involved Newark Mayor Ras Baraka and other lawmakers. Court documents allege that McIver slammed her forearm into a federal officer attempting to arrest Baraka. McIver has argued that the Speech or Debate Clause of the Constitution shields her actions as legislative oversight.
In August a three-judge panel held that the charged conduct outside the facility was “unambiguously non-legislative” for two of the counts and sent the third count back for further district-court review. Thursday’s order stated that no judge who concurred in the panel decision requested rehearing and that a majority of active circuit judges did not vote to rehear the case. Three judges voted to grant the petition.
McIver issued a statement saying the result is “frustrating” and that she and her lawyers are examining every option. She has previously said the case is the product of a “weaponized” Justice Department and that she faces up to 17 years if convicted. The Justice Department has maintained that the charges concern physical interference with federal officers, not protected legislative activity.
The August panel opinion, written by Judge Cindy Chung (joined by Judge Stephanos Bibas), rejected the immunity claim for the counts tied to the altercation itself. A partial dissent took a different view of one contact and of discovery on selective-prosecution claims. The full-court denial keeps that framework in place.
McIver could next petition the Supreme Court. The case remains one of the few recent instances in which a sitting member of Congress faces criminal charges related to an interaction with federal immigration enforcement personnel during an oversight visit.
The underlying incident occurred in May 2025. Lower courts had already declined to dismiss the case before the August appellate ruling. Thursday’s decision moves the matter closer to possible trial on the surviving counts.
Join the Team
Are you trying to break into news writing but struggling to get published at major outlets? At RWT News, we're always looking for talented, motivated writers who share our commitment to straightforward, factual conservative journalism. If you believe in honest reporting and want real experience and bylines, we'd love to hear from you.
Visit our Join the Team page to learn more and contact us directly.
